Every driver hears these. Some contain a real kernel, some backfire, and one or two could cost you a catalytic converter. One promise up front: we ran no tests for this page, and we invented none. Each verdict below is checked against published evidence — emissions-programme guidance, the Top Tier fuel standard, established OBD-II behaviour, and this site’s own published code pages — and where the published evidence is thin, the verdict says so instead of pretending otherwise.
Verdict: PARTLY TRUE.
A loose gas cap is a genuine, common cause of the small-leak EVAP codes — P0442 and its very-small-leak sibling P0456 are exactly the codes a cap that was not clicked shut, or whose seal has cracked with age, can set. So checking and re-seating the cap costs nothing and is the right first move for those codes. The myth is in the “and the light goes away” part. The car does not re-test the EVAP system the moment you tighten the cap: the monitor runs only under its own set conditions, over subsequent drive cycles. If the cap really was the leak, the light clears on its own after that driving — not in the driveway. And if the light stays on, the leak is somewhere else (a hose, a valve, the filler neck) and the cap was never it. Tighten it, drive normally for a few days, and let the re-test deliver the verdict.
Verdict: MYTH — and it backfires.
Disconnecting the battery does turn the light off. It also resets every readiness monitor to “not ready” — and state inspection programmes check exactly that. Emissions authorities (New York’s DMV guidance is a clear published example) state plainly that a vehicle whose monitors are not ready will not pass its OBD inspection, and that a recent battery disconnect or code clear is a standard cause. So the trick trades a fail for a fault into a fail for “not ready,” plus a second trip once you have driven enough drive cycles to set the monitors again. Worse, clearing also erases the freeze-frame data — the snapshot of speed, load, and temperatures recorded when the fault set — which is some of the most useful evidence whoever diagnoses the car (including future you) will ever get. Expect some relearn quirks after any disconnect, too; see our battery relearn guide. Fix the fault, then drive: that is the only route that passes.
Verdict: MYTH.
For a car that does not require premium, this confuses two different things. “Premium” is an octane grade: octane is resistance to knocking, nothing more, and extra octane in an engine that cannot use it adds no cleaning power. The real distinction the myth is groping toward is Top Tier detergent gasoline — a genuine, licensed fuel standard, founded by a group of automakers, that requires detergent levels above the regulatory minimum. Crucially, Top Tier applies across all grades at a licensed brand: regular from a Top Tier station carries the detergent package; premium from a station that is not Top Tier licensed does not automatically. So if you want the cleaning benefit, buy the brand standard, not the octane number. And keep expectations honest: detergent gasoline helps limit deposit build-up over time. It does not repair a fault that has already set a code, and no tank of any gasoline switches a check-engine light off. If your manual requires premium, of course, use it — that is an octane requirement, not a cleaning claim.
Verdict: PARTLY TRUE / UNPROVEN.
The oldest myth on this page, and the one with the thinnest evidence either way. The kernel of truth: sustained load and rpm do raise combustion temperatures, and older-era guidance and owner reports credit hard, sustained running with easing some combustion-chamber deposits on some older engines — a car that only ever short-trips can genuinely run better after a proper highway run. The limits are just as real. Published analysis of direct-injection engines points out that their intake valves are cooled by the incoming air and do not reach the temperatures needed to burn hardened valve deposits away — no amount of enthusiastic driving substitutes for physically cleaning them. And an Italian tune-up is not a repair for anything that has set a code. One hard rule overrides all of it: never do this with an active misfire. A misfiring cylinder passes raw fuel into the exhaust, where it overheats the catalytic converter — the very reason a flashing check-engine light means stop. If you have a misfire code such as P0300, fix the misfire first; the spirited drive can wait until the car is healthy. Verdict stands at partly true for light cases on some engines, unproven as a general cure, and harmful in the misfire case.
Verdict: MYTH.
This is the misunderstanding this whole site exists to correct. A code names a circuit or condition the computer detected — a reading out of range, a response too slow, a leak too big — not the component that caused it. A lean code can be a vacuum leak, low fuel pressure, a lying airflow sensor, or an exhaust leak ahead of the oxygen sensor; the oxygen sensor reporting it is usually the messenger. Replacing the named part without testing the circuit is how a cheap fault becomes an expensive tour of the parts catalogue. Read the code as the first clue, test to find the cause, and when several codes arrive together read them as a set — that method is laid out in our code-combinations guide.
Verdict: PARTLY TRUE.
Sometimes, yes. For a genuinely intermittent fault — a code that set once under odd conditions and never repeats — clearing it after writing the code and its freeze-frame data down, then driving and watching, is a legitimate diagnostic step: whether and how fast it returns is information. The “always” is where the myth breaks. Do not clear-and-watch on a misfire that happens under load, on anything safety-related, or on a fault the car is actively warning you about — and understand that clearing also resets the readiness monitors (see the battery myth above), which matters if an inspection is due. One rule outranks every other on this page: a flashing check-engine light means a severe misfire is happening now and can damage the catalytic converter — stop driving. That is not a clear-it-and-see situation; it is a park-it-and-fix-it one. Steady light: get the code read soon. Flashing light: stop.
Notice what the true halves have in common: they are all cheap first checks and honest observation — seat the gas cap and drive, write the code down before clearing anything, read codes as clues and test before buying. The myth halves all promise a shortcut around diagnosis itself. There isn’t one. There is just diagnosis done in the right order, which is what the rest of this site is for: start with reading your codes as a set, or look a single code up in depth from P0442 onward.